Redundancy consultation meetings are some of the most sensitive and high-stakes conversations in the employment lifecycle. Leaders often feel anxious, emotional, or afraid of “saying the wrong thing.” Employees often feel shocked, overwhelmed, and uncertain about what comes next.
Across New Zealand and Australia, the legal requirement is clear:
Redundancy can only be lawful when preceded by a fair, genuine, and well-structured consultation process.
The consultation meeting is not a formality.
It is the core of that process.
A poorly handled consultation meeting can:
- damage trust,
- increase conflict,
- trigger legal claims,
- undermine the legitimacy of the restructure, and
- harm wellbeing.
A well-run consultation, however, feels:
- respectful,
- transparent,
- human,
- balanced,
- and legally defensible.
Here’s exactly how to run a redundancy consultation meeting safely, calmly and professionally across the ANZ region.
1. Prepare properly — don’t walk in guessing
Before the meeting, ensure you have:
- a clear restructure proposal document,
- the business rationale,
- impact on roles,
- proposed selection criteria (if applicable),
- timelines for feedback,
- notes on alternatives considered,
- a plan for redeployment options,
- support information (EAP, leave options), and
- clarity around what has and has not been decided.
If you’re unclear, the employee will be too — and that’s unfair.
2. Start the meeting with calm clarity
Begin by setting the tone.
You want the employee to feel respected and safe — even if the content is difficult.
Try something like:
“Thank you for meeting with us today. We need to talk through a proposed organisational change. No decisions have been made — this is the start of consultation. We’d like to share the proposal with you, hear your feedback, and talk through what this could mean for you.”
This immediately signals:
- safety,
- fairness,
- no predetermined outcomes.
This phrase alone prevents half of all claims.
3. Present the proposal neutrally — not emotionally
Stick to facts, not emotion or speculation.
Explain:
- why the change is being proposed,
- what the proposed change is,
- which roles are impacted,
- how the proposed structure would work,
- what alternatives have been considered,
- what the potential impacts are for the employee,
- when feedback is due,
- how the decision will be made.
Avoid saying:
- “Your role is redundant” (this is unlawful at consultation stage)
- “Your job is definitely going” (predetermined outcome)
- “We’ve already decided”
Use clear, neutral phrasing:
- “Your role may be disestablished as part of the proposal.”
That single word — may — matters.
4. Pause and allow space — silence is part of fair process
Employees often need a moment to absorb the information.
Let the silence exist.
You can say:
“Take your time — this is a lot to process.”
This shows humanity and care, without drifting into legal risk.
5. Invite questions, thoughts and initial feedback
The goal of consultation is genuine consideration of employee feedback.
Ask:
- “What are your initial thoughts?”
- “Is anything unclear?”
- “Do you have ideas or alternatives we should consider?”
- “Is there anything you think we may have overlooked?”
You’re not seeking agreement — you’re seeking insight.
6. Be prepared for emotion (yours and theirs)
Redundancy proposals are emotional.
Employees may feel:
- shocked,
- angry,
- tearful,
- defensive,
- numb,
- panicked.
Respond with:
- calm,
- empathy,
- validation,
- reassurance about process.
Use phrases like:
- “I can see this is difficult news.”
- “Your response is completely understandable.”
- “We’re here to support you through the process.”
Do NOT say:
- “Try to stay positive.”
- “It’ll probably be fine.”
- “We all have to make sacrifices.”
These diminish the employee’s experience.
7. Explain what happens next
Clarity reduces fear.
Cover:
- how long consultation is open,
- how to provide feedback (written or verbal),
- what the decision-making process involves,
- when a final decision will be communicated,
- options such as redeployment,
- support services available.
You might say:
“We won’t make any decisions until we’ve fully considered your feedback. You can share it any time before [date].”
This is essential for legal defensibility.
8. Confirm the employee can bring a support person
This is mandatory in NZ
and strongly recommended in AU.
If they don’t have one today, reassure them they can bring someone to future meetings.
9. Document the meeting — cleanly and carefully
Document:
- what was shared,
- questions asked,
- answers provided,
- timeframes discussed,
- support offered.
This protects both parties — and is often vital if a claim is raised.
10. Follow up in writing
After the meeting, send an email that:
- summarises key points,
- attaches the proposal document,
- confirms feedback timelines,
- outlines next steps,
- includes support contact information.
Documentation = legal protection.
Common mistakes employers make (ANZ-wide)
- treating consultation as a formality
- using language that suggests the decision is already made
- giving too little detail
- giving too much detail (overwhelming or confusing)
- failing to prepare managers properly
- rushing timelines
- avoiding questions
- failing to explore redeployment
- reacting emotionally
- not documenting the process
These mistakes are avoidable with structure.
One HR Unlocked client said:
“We dreaded the consultation meetings — until we used your script. It changed everything. Staff said they felt treated fairly, even though the news was hard.”
Clarity and care go a long way.
The bottom line
A redundancy consultation meeting isn’t about legal wording — it’s about:
- fairness,
- clarity,
- dignity,
- transparency,
- and genuine consideration of feedback.
Across New Zealand and Australia, a lawful redundancy depends on a fair, open-minded process, not a predetermined outcome.
Handled well, consultation builds trust — even in tough moments.
If you want ANZ-ready consultation meeting scripts, restructure proposal templates, selection criteria tools and redeployment guides, HR Unlocked gives you everything you need to manage restructures confidently — without the consulting fees or the legal jargon.
#HRUnlocked #Redundancy #Restructure #ConsultationProcess #FairProcess #EmploymentLaw #EmploymentRelationsNZ #FairWork #PeopleAndCulture #ANZHR #HRAdvice #HRMadeSimple